Law & Sovereignty

ICWA After Brackeen: What the Court Settled — and What It Left Open

The Indian Child Welfare Act survived the Supreme Court in 2023. Here is what the law actually requires of state agencies — and which questions the Court never answered.

The Indigenous Beacon Editorial Team

Few federal laws are as widely invoked and as widely misunderstood as the Indian Child Welfare Act. Passed in 1978, ICWA governs how state courts handle custody proceedings involving Native children. It is not a race-based preference program, and it is not a blanket rule that Native children must be placed with Native families. It is a set of procedural and substantive protections built on a legal relationship between sovereign nations and the United States.

In 2023 the Supreme Court upheld it. What that decision did and did not settle is the part most people never hear.


The Removals That Made ICWA

ICWA was a response to a documented crisis, not a theoretical one. According to the National Indian Child Welfare Association, Native children were being removed from their families and communities at rates of 25% to 35% in the decades before the law passed. Of those removed, roughly 85% were placed outside their families — even when relatives or Tribal members were available to care for them.

That pattern was not an accident of poverty or neglect casework. State and private agencies routinely removed Native children on grounds that would not have justified removal for non-Native families, and routinely declined to place them with relatives who were willing and able to take them in. ICWA was Congress’s answer to that record.


Who the Law Covers

ICWA applies to an “Indian child,” which federal law defines narrowly: a person who is unmarried, under 18, and either a member of a federally recognized Tribe or eligible for membership in one and the biological child of a Tribal member (25 U.S.C. § 1903).

That definition matters. Under federal law, each Tribal nation determines its own membership requirements, and only the Tribe can determine whether a child is a member or eligible. The protections rest on a child’s political status as a member of a sovereign nation — not on a racial classification. That distinction is the legal foundation the whole statute stands on, and it is the ground the 2023 litigation attacked.


What the Law Actually Requires

In a case where ICWA applies, state and private agencies carry obligations that go beyond ordinary child welfare practice:

These obligations apply whether or not the Tribe chooses to participate in the case. A state cannot treat ICWA as optional because a Tribal government has not entered an appearance — the requirements are the state’s to meet.


What the Law Does Not Do

ICWA does not apply to every case involving a Native family. It generally does not govern custody disputes between parents or family members, such as divorce proceedings. It does not apply to juvenile delinquency proceedings for acts that would be crimes if committed by an adult. And it does not apply to cases already under Tribal court jurisdiction, because those courts are not state courts applying state law.

It also does not guarantee an outcome. ICWA sets a process and a set of preferences; it does not override a court’s obligation to protect a child from harm. Much of the practical fight over the law happens in the gap between those two things — in how thoroughly an agency documents its active efforts, how early it notifies a Tribe, and whether a judge holds it to the standard.


Brackeen: What the Court Decided

The challenge that reached the Supreme Court was Haaland v. Brackeen, 599 U.S. 255 (2023), brought by the states of Texas, Louisiana and Indiana along with individual plaintiffs and consolidated with three related cases, including Cherokee Nation v. Brackeen. The plaintiffs argued that ICWA exceeded Congress’s authority and violated the Constitution’s guarantee of equal protection.

On June 15, 2023, the Court ruled 7–2 to uphold the law. It rejected two of the constitutional challenges — the ones brought by Texas and by the private parties — and dismissed two others for lack of standing, according to NICWA’s account of the decision.

The practical effect was unambiguous: ICWA remains the law of the land, and states must follow it.


What Brackeen Left Open

The decision was a victory, but it was not a complete one — and reading it as the end of the fight would be a mistake.

Because the Court dismissed the equal protection challenge to ICWA’s placement preferences on standing grounds, it did not reach the merits of that question. A plaintiff with proper standing in a future case could bring the same argument again. That is not a prediction that the law will fall; it is simply what a standing-based dismissal leaves on the table.

And the daily reality of the law is decided far from the Supreme Court. ICWA’s protections are only as strong as the compliance behind them — whether caseworkers document active efforts, whether Tribes are notified in time to intervene, whether judges enforce the placement preferences, and whether states fund the culturally specific services the law contemplates. A statute that is upheld in Washington can still be under-enforced in a county courthouse.


Why This Belongs in the Classroom

For educators, ICWA is one of the clearest cases available for teaching the difference between race and political status in federal Indian law — and for showing students that the removal of Native children is not a closed chapter of history but a live area of law with ongoing litigation and ongoing consequences.

It is also a reminder of why the details matter. The headline from 2023 was that the Supreme Court saved ICWA. The work since is making sure that decision means something in an actual courtroom, for an actual family, on the day it counts.

Sources

  • · National Indian Child Welfare Association, “What is ICWA?” — https://www.nicwa.org/what-is-icwa/
  • · Haaland v. Brackeen, 599 U.S. 255 (2023) — https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haaland_v._Brackeen
  • · Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978, 25 U.S.C. § 1901 et seq. (definition of “Indian child” at § 1903)

This article is part of The Indigenous Beacon’s Law & Sovereignty series. Where the effect of a ruling is a matter of legal interpretation rather than a holding of the Court, we say so.